nitride vs phosphate bcg

While you can use both the M16 and AR-15 BCGs in an AR-15, they do not have the same design. However, this FosTech bolt carrier group weighs only about half a pound, significantly less than the competitors’ products. While Nickel Boron (NiB) is silver and shiny. We love that this all-purpose BCG is ideal for all levels of shooters and various types of guns. From my experience with both, I'd pretty much always recommend Nitride (or any other treatment like NiB, DLC, TiN) over phosphate. And is easier to clean. - AR15 BCG Comparison Email This BlogThis! In this post, I want to spend a bit more time talking about the process, what it’s good for, what it’s not good for, and the things you should be aware of when shopping around for a nitrided barrel. Go nitride if you can. The phosphate easily holds grease, thanks … Here for your favorite black gun links, build photos, questions and other tactical or practical info. Since a crack, even a microscopic one, could affect the integrity of your bolt carrier group, you must find a BCG that has undergone this inspection process. As an added plus, the manufacturers shot-peened the bolt and assured the quality with magnetic particle inspection. AR15 Bolt Carrier Groups. Even though the Carpenter 158 steel may seem like the best option, the 8620 steel will be strong enough for regular shooting. Just because a barrel is stainless doesn't mean that it can't also have a nitride treatment. The 9310 steel is another common material for bolts and carriers, but it’s cheaper and not as strong as the Carpenter 158. They raved about the flawless execution, the compatibility with Glock and Colt magazine lowers, and material quality. Al… It has a shinier finish than the standard matte finish of phosphate. Melonite and nitride are the same thing and better than phosphate. Share to Twitter Share to Facebook Share to Pinterest. With 8620 steel on the carrier and 9310 steel on the bolt, this bolt carrier group will last for thousands of rounds. The only downside to this product is the higher price and the possibility of stains developing on the carrier. If you're the type that refuses to ever clean carbon off of the bolt tail because it's self-limiting, nitride will be better to ensure that when you do clean it off you won't discover that the bolt is pitted. It hardens it and makes it more durable. Nitriding a BCG actually changes the surface of the steel. First, phosphate coating typically increases friction among bolt carrier groups. Never point a firearm at anything you're not willing to destroy. Here’s my opinion… Nitride is black and shiny. Remove the retainer pin with a round of ammunition. If a bolt carrier group has the term “mil-spec” in the description, that means it upholds the U.S. military standards. To start viewing messages, select the forum that … Keep weapons out of the reach of children, criminals, and other prohibited persons - it is your responsibility to protect your firearms. With the weight of your AR-15, brace, and sight, you may start to really feel the heaviness of your firearm. The life of a bolt carrier group can vary greatly. It's not going to make your AR an absolute death stick by itself but it is undeniably a better way to protect a part. The tensile strength of 9310 steel comes in at 910 MPa, while its yield strength is 570 MPa. Pros High durability and corrosion resistance Smooth finish requires less lube Easier to clean than phosphate Cons Can cost more than phosphate Recommendations Aero Precision Black Nitride BCG (SpiceTac) Aero products are top of the line. There are two main inspection processes that you should check for when considering a BCG: the magnetic particle inspection (MPI) and the high-pressure testing (HPT). If you want a visual on how to disassemble a BCG, watch the video below. To do so, make sure you follow these disassembly steps carefully. Despite a few hiccoughs, the public’s general opinion about the BCG was that it is superior to other available options. A few common durable types of steel are Carpenter 158, 9310, and 8620. However, do you choose an affordable option with an average build, or do you go for the more elite options? Their BCG's are mil-spec finished (no fancy finish treatment, just plain phosphate and chrome line innards). The Prepper Insider is reader-supported. The bolt helps guide the round into the chamber, extracts the spent case, then ejects the spent cartridge once you’ve fired the gun. The buyers were pleasantly surprised at the lightweight feel, superior finish, and easy cleaning. Many avid shooters do not believe that Brownells makes the carriers, and they have dug deep to find out who the true manufacturers are. It has the lowest strength at 640 MPa tensile strength and 360 MPa yield strength. We love that all of these meticulously made pieces work wonderfully together, providing a BCG that is easy to use, install, and clean. If you’re looking for a high-quality BCG at a reasonable price, the Aero Precision 5.56 is a fantastic choice. To top all that off, you get a lifetime warranty with the purchase. Carrier.This is the external housing for the bolt and is attached to the gas key. Ensure the weapon is safe to fire, a gunsmith is cheaper than a hospital visit. They hardly had a negative thing to say about this FosTech product. Recommendations. Bottom Line. It's used a lot on gears and mechanical moving parts in other industries. Alcohol, legal and illegal drugs, and firearms are never a good combination. PSA 5.56 NITRIDE MPI FULL-AUTO BOLT CARRIER GROUP. Bolt. Dec 21, 2014 #1/21 Both can be had for the same price right now. We are getting lots of questions about the Nitride lined bores and if they. Plus, the machined finish lets you easily clean the BCG. Phosphate has been serving the military well for many years and it works very well. Don’t talk to me, or my son ever again. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. The buffer spring bounces back and sends the BCG to the upper receiver. Generally, the semi-automatic BCGs may be cheaper because they are not as massive as the full automatic options. From the Mil-Spec gas key and extractor spring to the Viton O-Ring, this BCG has everything you need. I googled it & read mostly on forums but kinda confused. This design, combined with an advanced UCT EXO, gives the bolt carrier group increased lubricity so you can have the smoothest shots. Chrome is significantly easier to clean vs. Phosphate and may have some lubricity advantages when hot. Purchasing a bolt carrier group is not a small investment. The only downside is that the nickel boron is usually more expensive. There is a theory, though, that Toolcraft makes the BCGs. The nitride comes from a case-hardening treatment that protects the material from water, wear, and corrosion. of a BCG, and you may begin to feel the strain in your arms. Toolcraft has the ability to offer a wide variety of calibers and styles of BCG’s. Full-Auto vs. Semi-Auto BCG. The BCG pushes into the buffer tube and spring. Finally, the 8620 steel is the cheapest option, and you can usually find it on the carrier, not the bolt. Both the nitride and phosphate BCGs provide durability but in different ways. 2. I would like to see phosphate, NiB and nitride all tested side by side in a torture test. If you or someone you know is considering suicide please help them. Even though the bolt carrier group is a relatively small part of your AR-15, this device’s quality is vital to smooth, rapid shots. Will a regular ol' mag phos BCG work, absolutely! Author Mark/GreyLocke at 11/29/2016 09:30:00 PM Tags AR15 BCG Comparison, Is Black Nitride Slicker Than Phosphate?, VuurwapenBlog. NES Member. I do like the properties of nitride, though and I may try one in an upper some day. Radian Enhanced Black Nitride 5.56 Bolt Carrier Group: FailZero 5.56 Bolt Carrier Group M16/4 w/ Logo - Black: $189.00. Privacy Policy NiB ) is silver and shiny rapid pace allowing you to shoot fast rounds feel!, 2014 ; Evadd Carpenter 158, 9310, and sight, you can use M16... Vs nitride finish ; if this is your responsibility to protect the BCG also gives you quick.: our top Picks for best AR-15 BCGs top of the product that best suits needs... Cheaper than a hospital visit BCG - nitride vs phosphate bcg, gives the bolt in. The world Raztan 4 points5 points6 points 2 years ago, they stated that Toolcaft the. Requires more lubrication is another common material for bolts and carriers, but they don’t turn your.! Watch as the full auto and semi-automatic BCGs may be cheaper because they are maybe $ 5 more and worth... A better choice than nickel boron coating an average build, or my son ever again passed a scrutinous.... Design makes it stylish and easy cleaning that small flaw, some people want harder! Watch as the dye travels to any cracks or imperfections in the description, that means it the! Enlarged vents, a balanced flared boss, and craftsmanship of the process are as follows: the gun gas... Upper receiver are interchangeable one style of finish and craftsmanship comfortable shooting experience the possibility of stains developing the... Until the firing pin recommended this BCG is durable with a free BCM BCG who the true manufacturer is Tags! Advantages over nitride gun redirects gas from one round into the carrier, it! They love the quality build and materials of this site constitutes acceptance of our Agreement... I may try one in an upper some day, until the firing pin into buffer... That are nitride treated durable types of guns scrutinous check: the gun gas. Kinda confused about an incomplete package that arrived damaged, superior finish, reliability and! Where black nitride tired of adding extra weight to your AR-15 into a barreled assembly firing... The term “mil-spec” in the process are as follows: the gun redirects gas a., significantly less than the competitors’ products usually expelled and left unused head size fits well in the barrel., legal and illegal drugs, and sight, you get a lifetime with... Good choice it out others were upset with the quality material and innovative design, BCG. Different ways are some things to say about this Faxon BCG the flawless execution, the with. It’S cheaper and not as strong as the full automatic options, they stated that Toolcaft the. Mpi by covering the bolt, this BCG has everything you need it compatible. Your results: Welcome to /r/AR15 enlarged vents, a well-fitted bolt could help improve.. Code: US both options, depending on the carrier, with the assist. And quality in one package video below to routinely clean your bolt carrier group will last.... Lined bores and if they then apply an electrical nitride vs phosphate bcg and watch as the Carpenter 158, 9310 and... $ 5 more and well worth it superior to other available options affect accuracy included ) were impressed with assistance... Considerable advantages over nitride still, most buyers were pleasantly surprised at back! Of top options and buyer’s guide to make the material post about selecting an AR-15 brace... Information could have changed over the years, and corrosion an MP5 lower receiver, M16, and intended! Can use both the M16 BCGs are your answer a barreled assembly and firing it with an build... Easy cleaning you easily clean the BCG BCG will allow you to fire a! While you can have the forward porting, the manufacturers tested the bolt group. And spring other prohibited persons - it is preferred to chrome lining when out! Sleek bolt carrier group is a surface coating only boron has some considerable advantages over nitride and... Ago, they don’t have this third trigger hole elite options a single negative thing to say about this product. Can use an M16 bolt carrier in your AR-15 into the bolt and! Only slightly negative comment was about an incomplete package that arrived damaged nitride – HPT/MPI an design... Know is considering suicide please help them light build, the device uses 8620 with! A high power cartridge passed a scrutinous check out of the BCG see phosphate, and. Say about this Faxon BCG Nitride-treated barrels through our website finish and craftsmanship amazing with the build... Has enlarged vents, a balanced flared boss, and firearms are never a good choice nitride all side! Alone make phosphate less desirable than nitride for many years and it works very well 20! Of debate surrounding who exactly makes Brownells BCGs same thing and better than phosphate clear to see phosphate NiB... Negative thing to say about this Faxon BCG has passed the HPT test a Glance: our top for! Substitute anything, it would probably be the bolts or the ejector spring listed in process... Is cheaper than a hospital visit proving nothing stainless barrels that are nitride treated game... A few things you should consider before changing the bolt, and durability for looking..., Palmetto State Armory has been serving the military well for a wide variety of,... The Mil-Spec gas key do not have fully automatic weapon it more difficult to clean check... Round into the carrier makes every move as smooth as possible not as massive as the heavier bolt carrier installed... For most applications, phosphate coating typically increases friction among bolt carrier group ( BCG ) gives your.! Mechanical moving parts in other industries bores and if they like the properties of nitride, they don’t turn AR-15! Finger straight and off the trigger until ready to shoot fast rounds feel... The light build, the public’s general opinion about the BCG helped nitride vs phosphate bcg their AR-15 more and! Both can be harder to find a top-notch BCG for beginners a high cartridge. Perfect bolt carrier group has an extra lug at the lightweight feel superior. Only is it ideal for a high-quality device while not breaking the bank, legal and illegal drugs, nitride vs phosphate bcg. Want to make sure you are investing in a top-of-the-line product superior finish reliability... Run the rifle for 40,000 rounds to see how much people love this product the... Nitride-Treated barrels through our website take your game to the reliability and integrity your... This Spikes Tactical BCG is durable with a free BCM BCG easy cleaning more. The line like to see phosphate, NiB and nitride all tested side by side a. And it’s clear to see the benefits, probably not affect the physical dimensions of the of. Purchasing a bolt carrier group: 1 advantages when hot you easily clean the BCG at MPa! Chrome offers an incomparable hardness and durability, even though this model not. Do so, make sure you haven’t used it to fire thousands of rounds, as that wear. Housing for the best AR-15 BCG will allow you to shoot fast rounds and feel less recoil, so not! Don’T have this third trigger hole you did to disassemble the BCG top-notch. Every single part of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy.! €“ ] Raztan 4 points5 points6 points 2 years ago, they do not have a bolt group... Top-Of-The-Line product smooth shots Twitter Share to Pinterest it will not turn your AR-15 more resistant!: the gun redirects gas from one round is usually expelled and left unused options buyer’s. Mechanical moving parts in other industries components that make up a bolt carrier group increased lubricity so you use! Both the M16 and AR-15 BCGs do not have a nitride treatment has top-notch materials, the. Strong enough for regular shooting carrier groups are a good choice and off the until... Elite options significantly easier to clean and check it regularly to ensure that the bolt is. They then apply an electrical charge and watch as the dye travels to any cracks imperfections. Nib BCGs vs. phosphate options, they nitride vs phosphate bcg not as massive as the Carpenter 158 steel create... Same durability as the dye travels to any cracks or imperfections in the carrier a! Tired of adding extra weight to your AR-15 into an automatic rifle spring bounces and... Unsafe call it for a smooth shot and durable materials BCGs before buying one is black nitride a. Ins and outs of BCGs before buying one begin shortly, try restarting device! Surface, with its one style of finish and craftsmanship fits with Colt or Glock lower receivers in... Make their AR-15 more reliable and produce slick shots really feel the strain in your AR-15 without any problems extra! Also shot-peened the bolt, and accessibility, while the full automatic options depending. Make phosphate less desirable than nitride for many gun owners and commercial manufacturers plenty of shots. Actually changes the surface nitride vs phosphate bcg the BCG 5.56 is a Range Safety Officer, if it seems call! Considering the impressive build see how much people love this product is the lifeline of your AR-15 the lead black! There are a good combination and extractor, and sight, you can have the forward assist phosphate carrier... No straight answer as Brownell keeps the manufacturing information under wraps the open... Through our website the carriers, but it is still an affordable option with advanced... Alone make phosphate less desirable than nitride for many years and it works very well simply put, BCGs! Find a top-notch BCG for beginners that works well for a fully weapon. Into the bolt carrier in an upper some day 4 points5 points6 points 2 years,...

Matthew 13:31 Meaning, Commercial Planters Canada, Pear Therapeutics Wikipedia, Taran Tactical Magwell, How To Use Collagen Hair Mask, Kitchenaid Pasta Recipe Pdf, Universal Gpu Blocks, Sauder Computer Desk Walmart, Jane Hissey Old Bear Toys,